USF
Must Stop Competing with the Private Sector
November 19, 2026
For decades, Republicans and Democrats have agreed on a key broadband principle: every American should have access to broadband from a private-sector provider, with public money reserved to help build connectivity where absolutely needed. In general, federal programs—at least four devoted to expanding networks—fund these missing service areas, on the condition that subsidies mostly go where private companies aren’t already building or serving. Yet these respective programs, particularly parts of the FCC’s Universal Service Fund (USF), repeatedly miss this constraint. Whether the FCC or Congress leads any USF reform effort, it must bar funding for providers that the private sector is committed to serving without government financial assistance—commonly known as unsubsidized providers. Anything less perpetuates a troubling waste of public money at best and, at worst, widely distorts competition and penalizes consumers.
To be clear, targeting scarce federal funds from competing with the private sector is not new doctrine. One only has to look at the Broadband, Equity, Access, and Deployment (BEAD) program from former President Biden’s infrastructure law, widely supported by Democrats, as a recent affirmation. Similarly, the Trump Administration’s refined BEAD rules and commitments, supported by most Republicans, partly centered on updated broadband maps to ensure the program’s target remains on unserved households. Even recent versions of the Senate Farm Bill being devised by Congress set a threshold that no more than ten percent of a grant area—an overly high amount nonetheless—can overlap with private-sector broadband providers.
Somewhere along the way, however, the FCC’s USF hasn’t had to adhere to or implement this simple policy across all its programs, despite many complaints. Take the High-Cost Rate-of-Return program for starters: recipient companies continue to receive funding no matter when a competitive provider shows up to bring unsubsidized service. No rebalancing effort has been initiated to reflect the changing broadband landscape. Instead, checks keep being sent to incumbent providers. That’s $2 billion-plus yearly in consumer-paid USF fees shuffling out the door in perpetuity without a proper call to reconsider.
Likewise, the USF’s Schools and Libraries Program has its own unique overbuilding struggles. Specifically, the program operates under a competitive bidding framework to reduce overall costs. Since its inception, these funds have built numerous networks by non-local providers, bringing basic broadband connectivity to local schools and libraries. By itself, that may not seem problematic, but these USF-funded providers have bigger visions: a craving to serve beyond the respective school or library boundaries. As a result, many of these entities want to expand their subsidized school and/or library networks to compete directly with broadband providers serving surrounding cities, towns, and rural areas.
This is not to suggest that there hasn’t been some USF containment, but it’s clearly not enough. For instance, the FCC prohibits using funding against unsubsidized competitors for the model portion of its High-Cost Program. Even there, however, it adopted fairly narrow definitions of competitive providers, adding little value.
The reality is that funding already-served areas does real damage. USF fees raise the cost of communications services, taking more from the paychecks of hardworking Americans as prices climb on nearly every product and service. At a time when the buzzword affordability represents real consumer pain, wasting federal funds this way is unconscionable, especially when this money can be shifted to support other communications-worthy needs or, dare I suggest, just not spent. How can policymakers justify unnecessarily inflating broadband costs for families already struggling to make ends meet?
This unfair practice also weakens the market for existing providers, forcing them to compete against government-subsidized rivals. It's like New York City’s government grocery store idea, and the harm it will do to neighborhood bodegas and food stores. Economically challenged areas can barely justify one private provider, much less two or more— with one running on the government’s dime—fighting over an exceedingly petite pie. Small providers facing this pressure have to slash and burn, not invest and grow, to avoid dreaded financial troubles. For larger broadband companies, this distortion often forces them to shift costs elsewhere, thereby punishing customers in other markets with higher prices, reduced investment, or fewer services.
Congress has been quietly debating USF reform proposals. There is a real concern that the conversation among self-appointed working-group members and House and Senate staff is focused entirely on how to grab money from a wider pool for payees. That’s shorthand for how they can keep spending at current rates without any structural improvements. No thanks. Real reforms, like stopping funding providers in competition with the private sector, may have been mistakenly sidelined for the time being. That would be a serious flaw in any final product, and one likely to generate major opposition from fiscal conservatives who believe in program integrity and reasonable limitations.
USF already deviates far afield
from American capitalism and drifts toward broken governmental interference in
the vibrant communications sector. But even if this is barely above the
tolerable threshold, it is unacceptable to allow the government to use its
largesse against the private sector in direct competition for services. Closing
this fundamental flaw is a necessity and must be part of any effort to “fix”
USF.



